Polarization and Politicization of Climate Change in Media Discourse: A Comparative Analysis of Italy and the United States

Authors

  • Naz Samina Department of Population & Health-related social research, The Agha Khan University, Karachi
  • Naseem Ali Department of Population & Health-related social research, The Agha Khan University, Karachi

Keywords:

Public trust, media discourse, populism, politicization of science, comparative analysis, climate communication are some of the subjects covered

Abstract

This study examines how politically driven, often populist narratives that undermine democratic values are used to depict climate change in Italian and American media. The study uses a sample of seventy-one items from eight origins, equally distributed by nation and political affiliation, based on data from Facebook postings that have gotten forty or more comments. The mixed-methods technique includes keyword-in-context research, theme modeling, qualitative content analysis, and keyness analysis. The results reveal significant national and ideological differences. For example, conservative media frequently utilize more politicized and populist themes when discussing climate change. This is especially true in the US, where skepticism is often associated with scientific validity and long-term progress in a divisive argument between "elites vs. the general populace." Italian media outlets take a more specialist approach when reporting on European institutions, politics, and the economy. American progressive media seem to be more politically active than their Italian counterparts, despite the fact that progressive groups in both nations usually concentrate their discussions on scientific and policy concerns. The tendency of conservative American media to take a populist stance and display suspicion of experts could account for this phenomenon. The findings demonstrate how public discourse on climate change is impacted by populist rhetoric and how various democratic frameworks affect the discourse's clarity.

Downloads

Published

2026-10-03

How to Cite

Samina, N., & Ali, N. (2026). Polarization and Politicization of Climate Change in Media Discourse: A Comparative Analysis of Italy and the United States. Magna Carta: Contemporary Social Science, 5(4), 308–324. Retrieved from https://journal.50sea.com/index.php/MC/article/view/2137